Country Living Near Tomah, WI: 4-Bed Farmhouse on 0.71 Acres for $175K

Single-story house and detached garage with a red car in a grassy residential yard on a sunny autumn day
DCIM\100MEDIA\DJI_0806.JPG

New Price • Tomah, Wisconsin • MLS #2036337

More House, More Land, Less Money: A Country Farmhouse Minutes from Tomah

23963 Flint Ave, Tomah, WI 54660 — $175,000

If you’ve been dreaming about trading a cramped lot for room to garden, park the truck, and actually see the stars at night, this listing deserves a close look. 23963 Flint Ave is a 4-bedroom, 1,560 sq ft farmhouse on a 0.71-acre rural corner lot just minutes west of Tomah. It isn’t in a subdivision, and it’s priced well below the area average.

One thing up front: this is a character home that needs some work. It’s best for a buyer who wants more space and a country setting, and who’s comfortable putting in some updates to build equity over time.

Quick Facts

List Price$175,000
Bedrooms / Baths4 bed / 1 full bath (main level)
Living Area1,560 sq ft, 1.5 stories
Lot0.71 acres, corner lot, rural
Garage3-car garage plus lean-to
Year Built1885
Annual Taxes$1,562
Price per Sq FtAbout $112

Is This Home Right for You?

A Great Fit If You…

  • Want to move from town or the suburbs to the country
  • Need more bedrooms and a bigger yard than your current home has
  • Have tools, vehicles, or toys that need a 3-car garage
  • Like to garden, can, or grow your own fruit
  • Are comfortable with DIY projects or managing contractors
  • Want to build equity through improvements

Maybe Not the Best Fit If You…

  • Are a first-time buyer with no budget for updates after closing
  • Want a move-in-ready, fully renovated home
  • Need more than one bathroom right away
  • Prefer city water, sewer, and a subdivision setting

What You Get: Farmhouse Space With Key Updates Already Done

This National Folk–style farmhouse has the classic layout country buyers look for: a spacious kitchen, a formal dining room, and main-floor laundry. Two of the four bedrooms have walk-in closets, which is rare in a home of this age.

Several of the big-ticket items have already been addressed:

  • New furnace (2025) — forced-air heat plus central air
  • New carpet (2025)
  • Generator hookup for peace of mind during Wisconsin storms
  • Fiber internet available — a big plus if you work from home
  • Appliances included: refrigerator, range, dishwasher, washer, and dryer

The Outdoor Space Is the Star

The 0.71-acre corner lot is where this property really shines for country buyers:

  • 3-car garage plus a lean-to, with a garage door opener, for vehicles, equipment, a workshop, or storage
  • Fenced garden with a compost bin and established fruit trees, so you won’t be starting from scratch
  • Covered concrete patio for summer evenings
  • A rural setting outside a subdivision, with the space and privacy that comes with it

What to Plan For: An Honest Look

This home was built in 1885. It has been cared for and updated in key areas, but buyers should expect a to-do list. Here are the things I’d tell any buyer to plan and budget for:

  • One bathroom for four bedrooms. Adding a second bath (or a half bath) is a common upgrade that improves both daily living and resale value.
  • Cosmetic and system updates. Expect some projects typical of a farmhouse this age. Get a thorough home inspection and use it to rank your priorities.
  • Full stone basement. Stone foundations are common in Wisconsin farmhouses from this era. Have your inspector check for moisture and mortar condition.
  • Private well and septic. Budget for a well water test and a septic inspection. Many lenders require them on rural properties.

Pro tip: If you’d like to roll the cost of improvements into your mortgage, ask your lender about renovation loans such as the FHA 203(k) or Fannie Mae HomeStyle. With these, you can finance the purchase and the upgrades together in one loan.

Why the Price Makes Sense

At $175,000, this home is priced to account for the work it needs, and that’s where your opportunity lies:

  • The typical home value in Tomah is about $261,400, and Monroe County is about $263,400 (Zillow, August 2026). That puts this list price roughly 33% below the typical Tomah home.
  • The statewide typical value is about $339,700, so Tomah-area buyers get far more house and land for their money.
  • At about $112 per square foot, this home is well below Tomah’s recent median sale price of $136 per square foot (Redfin).
  • Annual taxes are just $1,562, which keeps your monthly payment manageable.

Why Buyers Are Choosing the Tomah Area

Tomah sits in the heart of Monroe County. It’s a small-town community with a surprisingly strong economy, easy highway and rail access, and plenty of outdoor recreation. Here’s why country buyers keep landing here.

1. Stable, Close-to-Home Jobs

  • Fort McCoy had an estimated $1.6 billion total economic impact in fiscal year 2024. Of the 1,934 personnel who work there, about 66% live in Monroe County.
  • The Tomah VA Medical Center sits on a 173-acre campus in town. It serves tens of thousands of veterans across Wisconsin and Minnesota and is a major local employer.
  • Jobs in Monroe County grew 5.5% from 2020 to 2025, from 22,796 to 24,042.

2. Easy to Get Anywhere

  • Tomah sits where I-90 and I-94 split, so getting to La Crosse, Madison, Eau Claire, and the Twin Cities is simple.
  • Tomah has its own Amtrak station on the Empire Builder route, which is rare for a town this size.
  • Wisconsin Dells and the rest of Juneau County are a short drive east.

3. Outdoor Recreation Right Outside Your Door

  • Lake Tomah offers boating, kayaking, and fishing, with two boat ramps and an accessible dock.
  • The Tomah Recreation Trail winds from downtown to Lake Tomah for walking, biking, and running.
  • The nationally known Elroy-Sparta State Trail is about 32 miles long, with its famous rail tunnels. The nearest trailhead, in Wilton, is about 18 minutes from Tomah.
  • Hunting, snowmobiling, cross-country skiing, golf, and disc golf are all close by.

4. Small-Town Living Without Giving Up Services

In Tomah you get everyday shopping, local restaurants, healthcare, parks, and schools. But at 23963 Flint Ave you get to come home to the quiet of the country.

Tomah Area by the Numbers

Metric Figure
Typical home value, Tomah$261,406
Typical home value, Wisconsin$339,699
Tomah 1-year home value change+3.1%
Fort McCoy economic impact (FY 2024)$1.6 billion
Monroe County job growth (2020–2025)+5.5%
Monroe County population (2024 est.)46,370

Sources: Zillow Home Value Index (Aug. 2026), Fort McCoy Public Affairs Office, Mississippi River Regional Planning Commission / Lightcast, U.S. Census Bureau.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is the farmhouse at 23963 Flint Ave in Tomah, WI?

It’s listed at $175,000 for 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 1,560 sq ft on a 0.71-acre corner lot (MLS #2036337).

Is this home a good fit for a first-time buyer?

It can be, but it’s best suited for a buyer who has room in the budget for updates after closing. A buyer looking to move to the country and gain space and equity is the ideal match.

Does the property have city water and sewer?

No. It has a private well and septic system, which is typical for rural Monroe County properties. Plan on a well test and septic inspection.

Is high-speed internet available?

Yes. Fiber internet is available at the property.

How do home prices in Tomah compare to the rest of Wisconsin?

Tomah’s typical home value (about $261,400) is roughly 23% below the statewide figure (about $339,700). That makes the Tomah area one of the better values in the state for buyers who want space.

Ready to See It in Person?

I’m Liz Walker with RE/MAX RealPros, and I help buyers and sellers across Tomah, Mauston, New Lisbon, Necedah, Elroy, Camp Douglas, Oakdale, Wisconsin Dells and the rest of Juneau and Monroe Counties. Reach out to schedule a private showing, or to talk about what country living near Tomah could look like for you.

View the Full Listing Contact Liz Walker

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Market statistics are from third-party sources as cited and are subject to change.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply